In this episode, Matt and Sarah describe their experience with orbs – lights in the sky over the Haw River in North Carolina in the fall of 2023 to researchers Joshua Cutchin and Barbara Fisher, coauthors of a forthcoming book about anomalous lights. The second part of the episode, Sarah…

In this episode, Sarah and Matt interview fishing guide Barrett Christiansen about his experience seeing a pink cryptid busting through the mangroves on the Florida coast with a six-foot long, pink and vertically compressed tail. And Sarah looks into the sea serpents of the southeastern US to find comparable critters…

In this episode, Sarah interviews UAP and paranormal researcher Barbara Fisher about her experiences with anomalous lights in the Appalachian Mountains near Athens, Ohio. They discusses the research Barbara is conducting to collect and categorize light phenomena in her forthcoming book with Joshua Cutchin. Check out Barbara’s Podcast 6 Degrees…

Episode art by Sarah Rose, featuring a Rough Green Snake climbing non-native sericea bush clover on the edge of the woods near our home. In this episode, we interview Andy Ciccone. Andy is the host of The Poor Proles Almanac podcast and author. His substack is an incredible wealth of…

In this Episode, nature writer and poet John Lane tells a story of his experience at the Bighorn Medicine Wheel in Wyoming in the 1990s. The story is incredible, full of high strangeness and aerial entities and the uncomfortable juxtaposition of the New Age movement and Native Traditions. We also…

In this episode, fly fishing guide Jimmy Lampros describes a strange encounter with an unexplained light in Western Maryland’s remote Savage River forest. Jimmy’s experience mirrors a passage from Harry Middleton’s incredible book about Appalachian brook trout fishing, The Spine of Time: At once, angling broadens a man’s vision while…

This episode Chris Daughters of the Caddis Fly Shop joins the show to talk about our 2008 Bigfoot footage from the McKenzie River and our experience on Season 1 of Finding Bigfoot. Then Sarah and Matt reckon with what happens when seemingly sane people are forced to seriously contemplate Bigfoot.…

Joshua Cutchin is the author of seven critically-acclaimed books: 2015’s A Trojan Feast: The Food and Drink Offerings of Aliens, Faeries, and Sasquatch (translated into Spanish as Banquete Troyano); 2016’s The Brimstone Deceit: An In-Depth Examination of Supernatural Scents, Otherworldly Odors, & Monstrous Miasmas; 2018’s Thieves in the Night: A Brief History of Supernatural Child…

In this episode Sarah interviews her sister Tessa and they discuss how violence can mark a landscape, and her experience with a ghost that followed her home from a favorite hiking spot in Los Alamos New Mexico. Encountering Tessa’s neighbors.

In this episode, Matt and Sarah outline the series of paranormal experiences that occurred, kicking off opening morning of the 2023 whitetail deer gun season opener in North Carolina.  Sarah showing Matt what a big deer looks like because he hadn’t seen any.